It’s an RPG showdown and we’re calling it.
“We live in a post-Skyrim age now, so comparisons between the two are inevitable. But they both define the RPG genre in very different ways…”
Fantasy RPGS are the staple of video video games, a hangover from the table-top gaming days of Dungeons & Dragons. Whatever different genres ebb and stream and change into widespread and fall out of favour (dusty army shooters, I’m taking a look at you), the fantasy RPG stays as strong as a rock, and simply as widespread. The fantasy style permeates popular culture: Games of Thrones, Lord of the Rings. Hell, even that obsession with vampires the world suffered from a number of years again might be traced again to our love of the fantastical, and our unquenchable thirst for olde worlde video games the place maidens had been honest, heroes had been forged from iron, and everybody bought wasted on mead and grog. In truth, Games of Thrones producers initially approached Bethesda to create a recreation based mostly on the collection. But Bethesda had been all like, ‘Nah, mate, we got our own thing going on.’ The consequence? The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim.
Today Skyrim, alongside CD Projekt RED’s The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt, dominates the style’s gaming dialogue. We reside in a post-Skyrim age now, so comparisons between the 2 are inevitable, if often lazy. Mysterious hero, examine. Swordplay, examine. Magic-wielding frighteners, examine. For the significantly informal gamer, at first look, hell at second or third look, they could even be the identical recreation. I’m not saying that one’s higher than the opposite (we’re higher than that, aren’t we?) – Skyrim and The Witcher three are each brilliantly realised opuses, and in case you haven’t performed both, it’s in all probability time to improve your Commodore 64 and begin questing.
But they each outline the style, in gaming a minimum of, in very alternative ways…
Skyrim vs. Nilfgaard
Remember while you first stepped into the province of Skyrim? That quickness of breath, coronary heart fluttering, as your creativeness runs wild. And you swear you’ll someday climb that distant snow-capped mountain even when it includes two hours of bunny-hopping throughout ledges not constructed for Nords. Nilfgaard, however, regardless of being round 20 p.c greater than Skyrim, feels a complete lot tighter. By which I imply, city planning feels extra pure and recognisable. A Polish pal as soon as mentioned that taking part in The Witcher three was like going again dwelling – presumably due to the gorgeous surroundings, relatively than the log shacks and ragged citizenry. The world of The Witcher three has a wild, medieval-like tapestry of color in all places, from flora to fauna to fortress. Which in all probability makes for the livelier environment in comparison with the near-desolate land of Skyrim exterior of metropolis hubs. These worlds additionally give us our first main distinction in the best way the video games discover the style: Where The Witcher three feels grounded in actual world imagery, Skyrim is solely imaginative fantasy.
Story and Narrative
You can nearly sum up every core story in two phrases apiece: Dragon-hunt vs. demon-hunt. Throw in a brewing civil struggle right here, a cruel invading military there and also you’re all set. Skyrim’s narrative construction and story are fairy-tale easy. That’s no unhealthy factor, since you possibly can probe for lots of of hours earlier than you decide up the following quest-line and nonetheless perceive what the hell is going on. The Witcher performs a special card – an in-depth story and a tightly managed narrative, with pseudo-adult themes, that’s been constructing because the 2007 authentic. But you’d count on that, what with The Witcher being based mostly on the books of Polish author Andrzej Sapkowski. Still, The Witcher three breaks the cardinal rule of online game story-telling: It takes management away from the participant throughout expository cut-scenes. Bah. But that’s completely in step with its literary origins, with The Witcher three taking part in out like an epic fantasy novel, whereas Skyrim may very well be seen as a online game model of Dungeons & Dragons: an expertise created by the participant, for the participant.
Dragonborn vs. Geralt
So who’re you? Look within the mirror, man, and inform me who you’re. Well, you’re both the ridiculously good-looking and angular Geralt of Rivia or… absolutely anything else inside your loopy thoughts. You wish to be a fats Argonian thief, you go for it. Because he’s pre-defined, Geralt is a stronger character within the conventional sense (i.e. regardless of your in-game selections, you would moderately guess how he would react to conditions within the supply materials), whereas Skyrim allows you to develop a singular persona in your wild-haired freak of a unadorned Dunmer. The video games have a look at two several types of fantasy exploration: spinning an epic yarn versus immersive escapism. So Skyrim provides up the want fulfilment character – you’re the story; The Witcher three is extra centered on following the story of a legendary hero.
Combat and Gameplay
“While both are pretty similar in their high fantasy style, their execution of gameplay, narrative and setting provides players with very different opportunities to create a world and blaze the trail in a way the other forms of fiction simply can’t provide.”
Both video games provide among the deepest gameplay you’ll see this aspect of the Mundus realm. Courtships and selections and combating for the precise aspect, relying on no matter you contemplate proper to be. That mentioned, fight in each video games at all times felt barely off.
In Skyrim, it might all really feel a tad unwieldy, until you’re Fus-Ro-Dahing a goat off a mountain. All proper, the controls aren’t as clunky as making an attempt to do, say, completely something in Assassin’s Creed: Brotherhood, nevertheless it’s not as silky clean as Batman: Arkham Asylum. That ain’t to say The Witcher three fares significantly better. It’s not as exact because it wish to faux (I’ve stabbed extra air than enemies, and I died much more instances in The Witcher due to my superior air-killing). I additionally discover Skyrim’s quest log totally overwhelming; a miserable to-do record I’ll by no means totally tick off (you possibly can add ironing to that, whereas we’re at it). And I stare in horror on the immense quantity of crafting choices in each video games. Not that it stops me choosing up every thing in sight, on the off-chance that I’ll want that stolen plate to avoid wasting the world (I received’t). But it’s the alternatives you’re provided as you progress that actually outline the sport. Skyrim focuses on crafting the hero you had been at all times meant to be, even in case you bought a D in maths in school. The Witcher three, however, in additional involved with shaping the story while you’re not in a tavern taking part in Gwent.
Freedom vs. Choice
And that dovetails with the largest distinction in the best way the video games discover the style: the place one provides freedom, the opposite is laser-focused on selection. Hear me out, and in case you disagree, I’ll volunteer my first-born as a sacrifice. Because proper now you’re rolling these fairly eyes of yours and both pondering ‘But both games feature freedom and choice,’ or threatening to do horrible issues to my mom as a result of I’m a no-nothing jackass. But there’s a refined distinction.
Skyrim is pushed by freedom; The Witcher three is pushed by selection. Sure, Skyrim serves up selection on a platter – character, dialogue, guilds, whether or not or to not kill each NPC in sight – however the recreation’s pull is the flexibility to go wherever, do something, ably assisted by an epic and devoted modding group. Freedom is what offers you a playground you possibly can sink 500 hours into and nonetheless hold going. Since The Witcher three’s fundamental focus is its narrative, the emphasis shifts to selection – the way you outline Geralt’s story and evolve the world round you.
Skyrim Versus The Witcher three: which is the perfect RPG?
Fantasy has at all times been about creating, discovering and exploring new worlds – in addition to escaping into them. And whereas each are fairly comparable of their excessive fantasy fashion, their execution of gameplay, narrative and setting offers gamers with very totally different alternatives to create a world and blaze a path in a method different types of fiction merely can’t present.
But okay, let’s think about the colonial armies have a sharpened sword to your throat and you may solely play one; you’re pressured to decide on the perfect. It’s a tricky name. While each Skyrim and The Witcher give us fantastical adventures which can be partaking and immersive, Skyrim is the sport that explores the fantasy style in the best way that solely a recreation can. It’s totally embraced the online game format – from creating your character to crafting your story – so it’s capable of provide gamers an enormous expertise different literary varieties can’t handle (and different video games simply can’t rival). I’ll drink to that; anybody for a goblet of mead?
Source
