Scalebound’s troubles had been seen in its two-sided previews

No Comments

E3 and Gamescom demos had warning indicators that every one was not properly on Platinum & Microsoft’s RPG venture.


Last night time some disappointing information bought out: Scalebound, Microsoft and Platinum’s venture into the RPG, is dead. Microsoft didn’t actually give an actual reasoning for the cancellation, although sources advised those that broke the story that there’d been extreme improvement difficulties and a communication breakdown.

“It seemed to me for a while that there were almost two Scalebounds: The one that Kamiya had dreamed of making, and the one Microsoft wanted him to make.”

That’s a fantastic disgrace, clearly, however as any person who sat by means of a number of press convention showings of the sport and had two non-public conferences with director Hideki Kamiya over the course of Scalebound’s prolonged improvement, a part of me isn’t all that shocked. It appeared to me for some time that there have been virtually two Scalebounds: The one which Kamiya had dreamed of constructing, and the one Microsoft needed him to make. At the time you give this stuff the advantage of the doubt and assume they’ll all pull collectively since they usually do – however on this occasion they didn’t.

“Weirdly, every single closed-doors demo of Scalebound was like a different game,” I tweeted within the wake of the announcement. What I meant by this, I went on to elucidate, was that in non-public demos it simply appeared like a extra cohesive, correct online game, and one the builders had a substantial amount of ardour for.

On stage, Microsoft all the time selected to current the sport in what I assumed was a wierd mild. It appeared as if they needed to lean on Platinum and Kamiya’s motion credentials, which is smart. The drawback with that’s Scalebound gave the impression to be way more moreover.

The strangest and weakest displaying got here throughout an E3 stage demo in 2016, the place the sport was proven operating a confusing-looking boss tackled with 4 gamers in on-line co-op play. It wasn’t the worst demo of the present but it surely was pretty underwhelming.

Heavily-briefed builders stored banging on concerning the ‘scale’ of the boss battle over and over, one thing which smacked of the rehearsed PR traces to me. Scale is what Platinum is thought for, they’d say. It’s epic, it’s loopy, it’s action-packed, and that is only a taster.

The factor is… Scalebound appeared like much more than that at any time when I noticed it in a much less public setting. At the final couple of Gamescom exhibits I used to be capable of step into closed-doors conferences with Hideki Kamiya and JP Kellams, two key employees on the sport, and the demos they gave confirmed a larger breadth of content material than an motion co-op recreation.

I bear in mind glimpses and teases of a correct RPG-like world to discover, with NPCs, cities and quest-givers. I bear in mind seeing a Resident Evil type Tetris-inventory system, which is all the time thrilling. There had been sections of the sport the place participant and dragon can be break up up, testing the participant’s skills. The focus of the final presentation I noticed was on the sport’s character development system, which had an attention-grabbing little twist to the RPG traditions.


The foremost character would evolve alongside a set path so he had expertise and skills that matched his design and persona, however to have a full stage of virtually Bethesda-level character customisation moreover that Scalebound would use its dragon companion. Having much less of a set template than the participant character you might take away or swap out physique components with some hokey in-lore rationalization about DNA or equip gear, all of which might change the dragon’s skills.

“I really liked a lot of what was on show. In a sense it gave me some Dragon’s Dogma games – it was a big budget Japanese game trying to do something different with the RPG genre.”

It was a cool wanting system, and in that demo I watched Kamiya swap out massive wings for smaller wings that provide much less flight however release the flexibility to placed on extra attack-focused physique components and so forth. It was a system that intrigued me and appeared to have some correct RPG depth, particularly when paired with how the dragon appeared to have a thoughts and AI of his personal that a minimum of partially now calls to thoughts Trico. Except, y’know, extra of an aggressive killer.

I actually preferred loads of what was on present. In a way it gave me some Dragon’s Dogma vibes – it was a giant finances Japanese recreation attempting to do one thing totally different with the RPG style with out being too shackled to an present sequence, too obsessive about the West’s profitable RPGs or certainly each abruptly. I preferred it.

The factor that is still bizarre to me is that little or no of this type of factor was proven to the general public – it was reserved for behind-closed-doors for media to jot down about and by no means launched in a video type or what have you ever.

Kamiya himself has taken situation with how Microsoft marketed Scalebound prior to now – “I don’t like their marketing,” he revealed on twitter on the finish of August 2014, presumably with that 12 months’s Gamescom recent in reminiscence, and I’m inclined to agree.

Basically, what was proven in high-profile demos and trailers of Scalebound was by no means remotely as handsome or as attention-grabbing because the stuff Microsoft repeatedly determined to indicate in intimate press conferences. They virtually felt like two totally different video games, a loud, brash motion recreation in a single occasion and a extra considerate, explorative RPG in one other. The reality was someplace within the center, it appears, and no person was totally happy.

“Those shits at MS… are they fucking with me?” the famously-outspoken Kamiya tweeted in July 2015. This in all probability ought to’ve been a much bigger warning signal, however Kamiya is famed for his twitter outbursts, so no person appeared too involved.

This was a little bit after an E3 Gamescom skipped and never lengthy earlier than a Gamescom the place Scalebound would demo. The publicly-released trailer there was among the best the sport noticed, however was nonetheless action-focused, and once more the reside demo given by Kamiya in a non-public room on Microsoft’s stand that 12 months was way more attention-grabbing and thrilling.

So… one has to marvel what occurred. There was a breakdown of communication, clearly, however I additionally assume it possible that in the end Microsoft and Platinum needed two very various things out of Scalebound. That could be what killed the venture, and that’s a disgrace, because the recreation I noticed behind-closed-doors appeared actually thrilling. Hopefully a few of the concepts from it should resurface elsewhere.