Not every player embraced that new vision at the time.
In 2025 the game marks its ten-year anniversary. Recently, Bethesda Game Studios head Todd Howard spoke with GQ and shared his thoughts on the game’s dialogue system.
During development of Fallout 4 the team aimed to craft lively, compelling conversations, but the experiment ultimately missed the mark:
…we spent what felt like an eternity on Fallout 4’s dialogue system. How do you make interactive dialogue engaging? How do you make it feel like gameplay? In the end, it didn’t connect. On top of that, our designers found it difficult to write in that style.
Todd Howard noted that players tend to prefer role-playing, and voicing the protagonist may not have been the best choice:
Players want more opportunity to role-play, yet we voiced the player character. The performers were outstanding, but many players said, “That’s not the voice I hear in my head.”
Source: iXBT.games