‘It’s basically garbage’: Critical Role founder doubles down on company’s controversial stance

As artificial intelligence continues to permeate the entertainment sector, it has sparked a fierce debate: are we witnessing the inevitable decline of human-centric artistry? While many creators are embracing the technology, others are standing firm in their commitment to pure human craftsmanship. Among the most vocal proponents of this traditional path are the architects behind Critical Role.

In a recent conversation with ComicsBeat, Critical Role co-founder Sam Riegel and composer Peter Habib dissected the role of AI within creative workflows. They specifically addressed the potential integration of machine learning into the musical scores for their animated series, The Legend of Vox Machina and The Mighty Nein.

“Our production remains entirely free of AI,” Habib stated, referencing the standout track “Who Will You Be?” from The Mighty Nein. He acknowledged that while some industry peers utilize generative tools as a “third writer” to break through creative stalemates, he maintains a cautious stance. He pointed to the rapid proliferation of automated content on streaming platforms as a concerning trend that threatens the integrity of the music industry.

For fans of the series, Riegel offered a definitive reassurance: AI has no place in their future projects. “To us, it feels like garbage,” Riegel remarked. “The irony is that AI was initially pitched as a way to liberate humanity, giving us more time to pursue art and fulfillment. Now, the narrative has shifted toward machines generating our poetry and music. That is the very essence of human experience; why would we ever forfeit that?”

Image: Prime Video

While Riegel acknowledges that machine learning may have practical applications in fields like software development, he remains staunch in his opposition to its involvement in artistic expression.

“The struggle of creating art is what makes the result meaningful,” Riegel concluded. “We have zero intention of incorporating AI into our work, now or in the future.”

Source: Polygon