You go about your life considering you’re the architect of your future. That your selections matter, that you could change your circumstances by making good calls and placing within the graft. Life can be a bit miserable in any other case, wouldn’t it? So you get up daily and also you do your finest, hoping for a greater tomorrow.
Then you fail to fend off the third of three rats throughout a QTE and also you and your mates are useless. Dead, pal. No reloads, no mercy. That’s you achieved.
Such is the knife-edge on which Man of Medan’s characters stay all through its five-hour story, following on in type and construction from Supermassive’s huge dumb enjoyable interactive horror Until Dawn. Like Until Dawn, it focuses on the lives of a gaggle of improbably adventurous younger folks trapped in unfamiliar environment. But not like the 2015 PS4 title, the precise flavour of horror doesn’t lean fairly so closely on the corny teen films of yesteryear. Out with ‘I Know Which Button You Didn’t Press In Time Last Summer’, in with a extra unique and involving story about an ill-advised (aren’t they at all times?) diving expedition whose members wind up on an deserted WW2 naval vessel after being kidnapped by pirates.
They’re likeable characters on the coronary heart of this story too, and that’s not a simple factor for an interactive horror author to drag off. Each character will, by necessity, make foolish selections that you simply’d by no means make in actual life, like venturing additional into the Scary Place, for instance. Otherwise the credit would roll 20 minutes in once they hear about an incoming storm and determine to pack in the entire dive, simply to be on the protected facet. Despite these crucial leaps away from genuine human behaviour, you understand and care sufficient about everybody to really feel a nurturing intuition in the direction of them.
The setup: millennial energy couple Alex and Julia carry alongside their respective brothers Brad and Conrad and rent Fliss the surly boat captain to sail out in the direction of a wrecked bomber airplane on the ocean flooring. And naturally they offer you a helpful snapshot of their character the primary time every of them opens their mouth. Alex the quietly self-confident med faculty pupil. Brad the anxious little brother. Julia the wealthy lady who doesn’t prefer to go on about it. Conrad, the – grasp on, that’s Shawn Ashmore! And Fliss, the designated ‘Never should have come here’ doomsayer.
Their interactions with each other – or relatively your decisions about how they speak with each other – carry refined knock-on results on their relationships, and personalities. The former’s fairly to simple to comply with – act like a dick in the direction of a selected character and their dialogue in the direction of you turns into frostier. Demonstrate that you simply’ve obtained their again, and also you’ll refill that relationship bar and so they’ll be kinder with their phrases to you. As far as I’ve been in a position to inform although, relationships don’t play any important function within the main story beats or variables that determine who lives or dies. As for personalities, frankly I’m baffled. For most of my first playthrough with Brad, two of his character traits have been truthful and deceitful.
This time there’s the chance to buddy up and play via all of it in native or on-line co-op, too. The expertise doesn’t range wildly from solo play in case you do – since many scenes occur concurrently in Man of Medan you simply play one or the opposite in co-op relatively than each sequentially as a lone participant. Conceptually it really works, however in reality it’s an actual atmosphere-sapper having another person within the game. You’re extra inclined to take the piss out of each little bit of hammy dialogue, and fewer prone to let the foreboding seep in. Plus, it’s a little bit of a nightmare to maneuver round in tight areas with arty digicam angles when there’s two of you. In brief: play alone on your first run via to get the very best expertise.
Reviewing a game like that is, after all, to stroll a tightrope between spoilers and unhelpful fuzziness, as a result of the particulars of the story are the entire expertise. And I’ve already given away the rat QTE, haven’t I? What I’ll say is that this isn’t practically as foolish because it at first appears. Man of Medan’s twists and turns are clever and satisfying, even when they’re telegraphed a bit too flagrantly – you’ll at all times be just a few steps forward of your solid of hapless pawns in figuring issues out, notably in case you take the time to learn the letters and artifacts dotted all through the game. Nevertheless, it seems like a extra mature effort than Until Dawn, taking itself extra severely and welcoming you to do the identical. There are bounce scares, sure, however the slowly accumulating atmospheric dread is the actual accomplishment in Man of Medan’s scary stakes.
It’s additionally helped alongside properly by interludes that includes The Curator (Pip Torrens). Here Man of Medan exhibits an appreciation for traditional horror anthology presentation, paying homage to Alfred Hitchcock Presents, The Veil, and The Twilight Zone. Like the presenters in these exhibits, The Curator is aware of greater than you. He is aware of greater than the characters whose lives you’re toying with. And because the conservator of darkish happenings in what seems like a dream or one other realm, he’s faintly amused by all of it. Excellently acted and offered, it additionally serves, you think, as a throughline between this and different Dark Pictures Anthology episodes.
You already know what the issues are. Flipbook-level body charges (on PS4 at the least), seemingly incidental QTEs that find yourself having a large affect on the story, and an excessive amount of uneventful strolling round. These have been the actual perils of Until Dawn, and so they stick with Man of Medan like glue. What’s particularly irritating is that double-team effort from the low fps and deceptively high-stakes QTES: it’s so simple to fuck up a timed button press within the beat-matching ‘stay calm’ sequences as a result of the speed at which button prompts seem onscreen is wildly off from the heartbeat audio cues you’re speculated to be syncing with. Because it’s all occurring at about 15 frames per second. The identical goes for less complicated QTEs the place button prompts name you to swift however easy motion, however they’re particularly troublesome within the former sequences.
But the primary playthrough’s actually extra of a trial run. It’s Bill Murray’s first day in Punxsutawney. Ashton Kutcher’s faculty dorm earlier than he begins studying out these journals. The ‘game’ is in determining all of the permutations of your actions and engineering your required consequence. Man of Medan throws you a bone on this regard through Life Bearings, accessible within the character menu. Here the game spells out what the large variables are, and the way your actions affected the end result of all of them. So if Character X died in your first playthrough since you made Decision Z in Life Bearing Y (forgive me, I’m attempting actually laborious to not spoil something), you simply hop again in for a second playthrough and make a special name when that state of affairs comes up once more.
Much just like the tragic heroes of Groundhog Day and its inarguable equal for high quality, The Butterfly Effect, although, you quickly discover that going again in time to repair one mistake usually results in a bunch of latest ones. That’s once more right down to the dearth of signposting – or look, let’s simply name it wilfully misleading QTEs – dotted all through the game. I wasn’t joking once I stated that one rat did for me and all my surviving buddies due to a single mis-timed button press. Five minutes earlier than the top of the game.
Once you’ve accomplished one playthrough you possibly can choose particular chapters to leap again in on a particular level, however doing so feels an excessive amount of like laborious work in case you go in feeling such as you have been cheated out of an consequence you’d fastidiously deliberate for within the first place. Things like the shortcoming to skip cutscenes or velocity passages alongside that you simply’ve already performed a number of occasions actually begin to grate.
So is it… y’know – good? Yes. In spite of its technical and interactive mis-steps, the journey inside Man of Medan is nicely price embarking on. If you could have even the slightest mushy spot for Quantic Dream’s press-X-’em-ups that is ambrosia – cinematic styling and engrossing tempo with out a SWAT workforce or gratuitous nude scene in sight. If the very point out of David Cage’s self-proclaimed interactive dramas has you drafting a tweet that you simply’re pretty positive will earn you a short lived ban, this gained’t sway you. Personally, I’m genuinely excited for future Dark Pictures instalments. And I’m nonetheless taking part in Man of Medan, determining its hidden traps and machinations, regardless of my frustrations with it.
Source
