Ryan Murphy’s “Grotesquerie” Receives Mixed Reviews

Ahead of the premiere of “The Shards,” the series adaptation of Bret Easton Ellis’s novel, early reviews have begun to surface online. Currently, the project holds a 56% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes based on 16 reviews, and a score of 62 out of 100 on Metacritic from eight critical assessments.

The primary grievance among critics is the show’s significant departure from its literary source material. Reviewers argue that the series fails to capture the unsettling atmosphere and psychological density that defined the novel. In an effort to extend the narrative, the creators introduced new subplots and conventional teen tropes, which critics suggest not only dilute the central mystery but also occasionally clash with the character depth established by Ellis.

Nevertheless, reviewers concede that the show may resonate with fans of Ryan Murphy’s recent body of work. “The Shards” has earned praise for its polished visual aesthetic, its blend of teen drama and comedic horror, and strong performances—with Igby Rigney, who leads the cast, receiving particular acclaim. Some critics have even drawn parallels to “Euphoria,” noting the series’ bold stylistic choices and striking cinematography.

Source: Film.ru