Parks and Recreation’s Spiritual Successor Dig Highlights Streaming’s Impact on Sitcoms

Comment Views: 0

Parks and Recreation might not have survived the streaming era. Its first season was uneven, with ill-defined characters and a strange romance subplot that went nowhere. In 2009, NBC gave the sitcom another chance, eventually soft-rebooting it with Adam Scott and Rob Lowe. In the 2020s, Netflix might have canceled it after six episodes, as it did Blockbuster.

So when Peacock announced a new comedy from Parks and Rec creator Mike Schur and star Amy Poehler, I was optimistic. If anyone could show that the genre still works, it seemed like the team behind one of the best sitcoms on television could.

But their new serialized comedy, Dig, is very different from Parks and Rec. Like that show’s first season, Dig is still trying to figure itself out, and mostly failing.

Adapted from Kate Myers’ 2023 novel Excavations, Dig takes place over one summer at an archaeological site in Greece. An overworked staff played by Poehler, Geraldine Viswanathan (Thunderbolts, Blockers), and Hugh Laurie (Veep, House) manages a team of horny undergraduates excavating ancient artifacts under the Mediterranean sun. It sounds like a promising premise for a Mike Schur workplace comedy, but the result is hard to square with the work of the man who created The Good Place and worked on The Office.

Dig-4

The biggest problem is the serialized format. Instead of settling into a 20-minute story that resolves by the credits, viewers get cliffhangers apparently designed to prompt another click on “Next Episode” in the Peacock app. Eight episodes may not seem like enough to establish a large cast and send them on self-contained adventures, but FX’s Adults managed it, so I had high expectations.

The story itself isn’t especially interesting. Poehler plays Elise, a grumpy archaeologist tired of being second-in-command. Casting Leslie Knope herself as an unlikable protagonist is a curious choice. When Elise’s boss Neville, played by Laurie, again refuses to retire at the start of the summer, she storms off and accidentally discovers an ancient statue at an abandoned dig site. She keeps the find secret, hoping to claim the glory for herself.

After the statue disappears under suspicious circumstances, Dig becomes a whodunit. Elise and her friends race to recover the artifact before it vanishes into the black market.

NUP_210254_01535_RF

That plot sounds closer to an action-adventure movie or a TV drama than a comedy. Schur and his writers find little humor in the world of archaeology, and Dig shifts between a contrived caper and an ensemble comedy whose supporting characters are often poorly defined. Still, a few cast members stand out.

Viswanathan is genuinely funny as Elise’s chaotic friend, who has failed at everything in her life and arrives at the dig seeking a second chance with her ex-boyfriend. She brings energy to an otherwise oddly buttoned-up comedy, and some of her best lines made me wonder whether she improvised them.

Dig-3

Fina Strazza (Paper Girls, Fear Street: Prom Queen) is another highlight as Patty, a frizzy-haired undergraduate with an unusual personality who often talks about her isolated childhood on a farm. She is essentially Dwight from The Office as a cute, awkward young woman rather than a psychotic middle-aged man. As a devoted Parks fan, I wish I had something positive to say about Poehler’s performance.

Dig lacks the deep bench of supporting characters that made Parks and Rec great, though a few recurring faces are enjoyable. Kayvan Novak, who plays Nandor in What We Do in the Shadows, is charming as the very Greek mayor of the small town where the show takes place. He also has a devastating crush on Elise.

Dropout’s Brennan Lee Mulligan has a hilarious guest role as the bumbling son of the wealthy older man funding the dig. In his episode, the archaeologists must placate the idiotic millionaire in hopes of securing more money. It offers a glimpse of what Dig might have been without the weight of its serialized drama.

Dig-7

A strange sadness also runs through the show. Unlike the dark comedy of local government bureaucracy in Parks and Rec, the story feels grim. The characters recognize, to varying degrees, that their life’s work is dying. Elise and Neville repeatedly say funding for digs like theirs is drying up and that the wider world no longer cares about ancient Greek pottery.

There are echoes of The Office and its small-town paper sellers facing big-box stores and online retailers, though the situation feels less relatable against Greece’s sunny backdrop. I don’t know whether archaeology really is in crisis or whether Schur invented that pressure to raise the stakes. Either way, he seems to be talking about more than archaeology.

The sitcom industry also appears to be drying up. Hollywood is struggling, writers’ room jobs are dwindling, and AI presents another problem. The entry-level work that gave Schur a path toward creating shows like Parks and Rec may not exist much longer. I don’t know whether he intended to tell a depressing story about the death of his industry, but in a sense, that is what he has done.

Unfortunately, it doesn’t make for great TV comedy.

All 10 episodes of Dig premiere Nov. 23 on Peacock.

 

Source: Polygon

Related articles

Search games, news and articles…

Enter at least two characters

Enter at least two characters