Over the final seven days, you may need seen there have been numerous new graphics playing cards shaking up our best graphics card listing. First we had Nvidia’s pair of RTX Super playing cards, the RTX 2060 Super and the RTX 2070 Super, and simply a few days in the past they had been joined by AMD’s RX 5700 and RX 5700 XT. Yesterday, I put all however a kind of playing cards face to face through the medium of some pretty graphs (see our Nvidia RTX 2060 vs AMD RX 5700 article for more information), so right this moment I believed I’d do the identical for the $499 RTX 2070 Super, its identically-priced non-Super RTX 2070 counterpart and AMD’s prime Navi contender, the $399 RX 5700 XT, to see how all of them stack up as top-tier 1440p playing cards and entry-level 4K jobbers. Which one will triumph? Only the bar charts can determine.
RTX 2070 vs RX 5700 XT vs RTX 2070 Super: How we take a look at
As per standard, to see how all three playing cards stack up throughout 1920×1080, 2560×1440 and 4K resolutions, I’ve run all of them by way of my normal games benchmarking suite. That consists of Metro Exodus, Total War: Three Kingdoms, Final Fantasy XV (with out Nvidia’s fancy HairWorks, TurfEffects, VXAO and ShadowLibs results turned on), Assassin’s Creed Odyssey, Forza Horizon 4, Monster Hunter: World, Shadow of the Tomb Raider and The Witcher III.
Paired with my Intel Core i5-8600Ok CPU and 16GB of Corsair Vengeance 2133MHz RAM, I’ve seen what every card can do on max settings at 1080p and 1440p, plus Medium settings at 4K, and brought a mean body price (both from their very own built-in benchmarks or from my very own repeated handbook gameplay checks) to see how they stack up in opposition to one another.
The playing cards in query are Zotac’s GeForce RTX 2070 AMP Extreme version, the Nvidia RTX 2070 Super Founders Edition and AMD’s Radeon RX 5700 XT. The latter two GPUs needs to be pretty consultant of their respective card classes, however I’ll level out that Zotac’s RTX 2070 might be one of many quicker RTX 2070 playing cards you should purchase right this moment. As a end result, this card’s outcomes ought to most likely be taken as a greatest case form of state of affairs versus one thing a bit broader. It’s most likely additionally why, in numerous circumstances, it’s not that far behind Nvidia’s RTX 2070 Super.
RTX 2070 vs RX 5700 XT vs RTX 2070 Super: 1080p benchmarks
Surprise, shock, all three playing cards can do at the very least 60fps+ at 1920×1080 with out subject right here. Sure, the RX 5700 XT may simply miss the mark in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey at this decision (this game specifically appears to have been a reasonably giant hurdle for this card generally), however usually, they’re all fairly succesful. Indeed, whereas the cheaper RX 5700 XT has a transparent drawback in Shadow of the Tomb Raider and Total War: Three Kingdoms, it’s really just about on par with its dearer RTX rivals in virtually the whole lot else right here – and miles out in entrance in Forza Horizon 4, too.
That’s fairly good going for a graphics card that’s $100 cheaper than the competitors, though I must also word that you simply received’t see any profit past 60fps in any way right here until you could have a excessive refresh price monitor. If you’ve solely obtained a daily 60Hz monitor, there are much more acceptable graphics playing cards accessible that will provide you with precisely the identical impact for a heck of so much much less cash, such because the Nvidia GeForce GTX 1660 Ti. Still, for the sake of science, that is how these specific playing cards stack up at 1080p.
RTX 2070 vs RX 5700 XT vs RTX 2070 Super: 1440p benchmarks
Moving on to 2560×1440, then, all three playing cards can just about do 60fps (or fairly darn near it) at this decision with out having to compromise on graphical constancy. Again, the RX 5700 XT suffers barely in Shadow of the Tomb Raider and Total War right here, however in any other case it’s just about neck and neck with the RTX 2070, providing equal efficiency in The Witcher III and Assassin’s Creed Odyssey and ever so barely nippier speeds in Monster Hunter: World and Metro Exodus.
Again, that’s fairly darn spectacular contemplating its cheaper price, and much more so when my RTX 2070 outcomes come from Zotac’s absolute beast of an overclocked GPU. Indeed, if I used to be searching for a prime tier 1440p graphics card and I wasn’t actually that fussed about Nvidia’s ray tracing assist, then the RX 5700 XT is an absolute no brainer right here – at the very least in comparison with its dearer competitors (my Nvidia RTX 2060 vs AMD RX 5700 vs RTX 2060 Super vs RX 5700 XT piece talked about above may persuade you in any other case, in fact.
RTX 2070 vs RX 5700 XT vs RTX 2070 Super: 4K benchmarks
Still, along with prime notch 1440p efficiency, the opposite foremost cause why you may be serious about shopping for one in every of these playing cards is so you’ll be able to dip your toes into that sharpest of excessive definition swimming pools, 4K. With the exception of Forza Horizon 4 (which isn’t included right here as a result of, let’s face it, you’re nonetheless getting manner past 60fps on Ultra settings throughout all three playing cards right here and would principally require a complete bar chart all to itself), you’re actually solely getting playable speeds on Medium high quality settings right here, and even then you definitely’re nonetheless operating the chance of coming into the city of Chops-ville in a few of right this moment’s extra demanding games.
However, as a primary foray into the world of 4K, the RX 5700 XT as soon as once more holds its personal in opposition to its dearer competitors fairly properly right here. Sure, it falls off a cliff in terms of Metro Exodus for some cause, and struggles a bit with Final Fantasy XV, too, however in any other case you’re as soon as once more fairly comparable efficiency with the RTX 2070 at this decision, and in some circumstances it’s even clutching the RTX 2070 Super’s coat tails as properly.
To be sincere, although, I believe it’s most likely value spending the additional cash on the RTX 2070 Super in case you’re focusing on this decision, because it’s not solely in a position to hit a extra constant 60fps in comparison with the opposite two playing cards right here, however it’s additionally extra more likely to proceed hitting that kind of pace additional down the road as soon as games begin to get much more demanding sooner or later (though, in fact, I believe you must most likely be contemplating both the Radeon 7, RTX 2080 or upcoming RTX 2080 Super in case you actually need a correct 4K card that doesn’t utterly cripple your pockets just like the RTX 2080 Ti will, because it most likely received’t be too lengthy earlier than the RTX 2070 Super’s competent Medium speeds grow to be competent Low speeds).
RTX 2070 vs RX 5700 XT vs RTX 2070 Super: Conclusion
Ultimately, although, I believe it’s one other clear win for AMD right here, because the RX 5700 XT someway manages to sandwich itself between every of Nvidia’s dearer GPUs whereas additionally coming in at $100 much less – which in my books is fairly darn nice worth for cash.
Of course, as I identified in my RTX 2060 / RX 5000 face-off, it’s value noting that the RX 5700 XT doesn’t have any ray tracing assist like its Nvidia rivals, so in case you’re completely determined for the bestest wanting shadows and reflections you’ll be able to presumably get proper now, then you definitely’re going to should stump up the additional money for one in every of Nvidia’s playing cards. Personally, that’s not an enormous deal breaker for me, as I’ve but to see a ray tracing game that’s 100% bought me on the thought of getting an RTX card – plus, although the listing of confirmed ray tracing and DLSS games is continuous to develop at a fairly regular tempo today, there are nonetheless treasured few of them that truly have it carried out.
However, I do respect that the RTX 2070 is a way more viable ray tracing proposition than its cheaper RTX 2060 sibling, so I completely get why some may choose to go along with the RTX 2070 despite the numbers. I’ll be doing an extra investigation into every RTX card’s ray tracing prowess very quickly to see what you actually have to do ray tracing correctly, however for now, I’d undoubtedly be tempted to go down the AMD path as soon as third occasion variations of the RX 5700 XT can be found with higher cooling than AMD’s blower fan mannequin.
