Dr. Luke Suffers Setback in Kesha Defamation Lawsuit

New York Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter determined that Dr. Luke, who is suing his former artist for defamation, will have to prove malice on Kesha’s part to win his case
Kesha
Kesha, November 2019 (Jeff Kravitz/AMA2019/FilmMagic for dcp)

Lukasz “Dr. Luke” Gottwald suffered a setback in his defamation lawsuit against Kesha, according to The Holywood Reporter. In April, the New York Court of Appeals upheld a prior ruling that the producer would be allowed to countersue Kesha for defamation. His claim originated from the pop singer’s allegations that he drugged and raped her, which he denies.

Today, in a new decision, New York Supreme Court Justice Jennifer Schecter determined that Dr. Luke’s defamation suit will be retroactively subject to expanded anti-SLAPP laws, which were passed in New York last year in an effort to tamp down on frivolous defamation suits deployed to suppress freedom of speech.

As THR notes, Dr. Luke will now have to provide convincing evidence that Kesha made her allegations with malice in order to win his claim. Kesha will also be granted the right to file a counterclaim for the first time since Dr. Luke filed his defamation suit, another provision granted by the anti-SLAPP legislation. The case is set to go to trial in forthcoming months; an exact date has yet to be determined.

When reached by Pitchfork, Dr. Luke’s attorney Christine Lepera gave the following statement:

Today’s court hearing was only about a technical legal issue: the burden of proof at trial. Dr. Luke would have filed this case regardless of the burden of proof.  At trial, Dr. Luke will prove to the jury, as he has always maintained, that Kesha spread a vicious lie to get out of her contracts.  Kesha refuses to make any claim against Luke that she had would have the burden of proof on—because she knows she would lose and that she is lying.