I solely have room for one ‘hobby’ game in my life, and proper now, it’s Destiny 2. But Destiny’s innumerable missteps have grow to be the stuff of business legend, and make no mistake: with Anthem, EA needs Destiny’s viewers.
YouTuber AztecCross says “the vast majority” of different content material creators at a latest Anthem occasion have been fellow Destiny specialists. That’s a transparent indicator of EA’s intent: Destiny’s YouTube and Twitch neighborhood has grow to be important to its success and its enduring place within the broader gaming dialog, and regardless of Anthem’s many variations from Destiny, EA needs the identical ecosystem. But does the game BioWare has constructed deserve it?
During the Anthem demo this weekend I, like many others, constantly suffered a bug the place loading screens would hold at 95%. That’s a disgrace, as a result of I largely loved what I did handle to play. Anthem has actual energy in areas the place Destiny, to the rising frustration of many, has been weak for the reason that begin.
For one, Anthem’s world is wealthy and energetic. The skills to fly and swim allow vertiginous and complex degree designs, with quests and secrets and techniques squirrelled away on the tops of cliffs or deep in underwater caves. What’s extra, there’s an enormous vary of natural world, with variable behaviour. Destiny’s worlds could also be stunning, however they’re flat and unresponsive by comparability to Anthem’s, and – aside from a single quest-giver – comprise no life however bland, dim enemies.
This speaks to a thematic distinction of their lore. Destiny is a mournful, postlapsarian wrestle: on every planet, you discover the rusting ruins of a distant Golden Age, now haunted by remorseless aliens whose genocide in opposition to humanity has killed individuals of their billions, leaving us with only one Last City. Anthem, in contrast, is all about life – its title refers back to the Anthem of Creation, a power of pure artistic power that’s harmful solely as a result of creation and destruction usually go hand-in-hand. It’s such a distinction with Destiny that I ponder if it was explicitly designed to be so.
Destiny’s worlds could also be stunning, however they’re flat and unresponsive by comparability to Anthem’s
There’s a number of summary nonsense in each mythologies, however Destiny’s babble concerning the Light and the Darkness feels the extra uninterested in the 2 – it shares so much with Star Wars’s 40-year-old Force. There are hints of depth: Toland the Shattered and Dredgen Yor’s infatuation with the Hive’s Sword Logic is a extra refined rationale for good guys turning evil than merely giving in to aggressive emotions. But after greater than 4 years, it’s irritating that each one we’ve ever seen are hints that Destiny’s basic forces would possibly signify greater than a binary and clichéd view of cosmological morality.
It’s additionally not communicated very properly. The unique game’s story, infamously, didn’t benefit the identify. What has adopted has a minimum of been coherent, however solely Forsaken’s story of the skinny line between vengeance and justice, and its portrait of an more and more determined Zavala, has risen to the bar of being attention-grabbing. There’s nonetheless no actual scope for significant engagement with the world, or its many factions or occasions. At least Destiny 2 has an in-game codex now, however in contrast to Anthem’s, it doesn’t actually cowl the fundamentals of its lore, which could deter newcomers.
I haven’t met a personality in Anthem who’s grabbed me
Anthem’s edge right here isn’t decisive, nonetheless. It’s nice that your character can have one thing resembling an precise dialog, however your interlocutors don’t appear very participating to date. I haven’t met a personality in Anthem who’s actually grabbed me, and their dialogue jogs my memory eerily of the maudlin blather that Destiny’s characters spouted again at launch. Humour, heat, and wit are missing.
Anthem’s novelty explains a number of the above, each the nice and the dangerous: extra time with the game would possibly reveal a personality who grows on me, or expose its lore as even dafter than Destiny’s. I’ve solely scratched the floor, and to date uncared for the factor that issues most: gameplay.
Gunfeel, splashy Supers, and the general ‘power fantasy’ they create continues to be one in every of Destiny’s greatest promoting factors, however there’s a lot that Anthem will get proper on this division, too. Sprinting and leaping comes with a punchy ‘pop’ as you hearth your boosters. Guns sound nice, although they’ll’t compete with Bungie for really feel and character. Third-person taking pictures simply isn’t the identical; I doubt Anthem will give us a legendary gaming weapon to match the BFG 9000, whereas Destiny has a couple of actual contenders in Gjallarhorn, Thorn, and The Last Word. There’s additionally a bit an excessive amount of sponginess to enemies, even primary ones, for my style – although Destiny is way from innocent on that entrance.
But what extra compelling fantasy is there than flight? Flying round in Anthem is an actual deal with, even when it does really feel a bit imprecise and ‘soupy’ to manage. I hope it will get tweaked or clicks with follow, but it surely’s already fairly enjoyable, and it’s tantalising to think about what would possibly come within the full game – aerial puzzles, races, or impediment programs, maybe. The sluggish, first-person schlep round Fort Tarsis is depressing by comparability, although the settlement itself has a brilliant, funky Moroccan vibe.
My greatest issues pertain to how we’ll play Anthem. Its lack of PvP is an issue for me. I’ve loved aggressive shooters since Half-Life Deathmatch, and the very fact Destiny can scratch this itch is a considerable a part of its enchantment. Information on Anthem’s endgame – more likely to be its most vital part, as Destiny exhibits – is restricted, however we all know it’ll supply matchmaking for each exercise, together with raids. I’m sceptical about that.
It took a matchmade group about ten minutes to resolve the straightforward colour-shifting puzzle on the finish of the Anthem mission named Triple Threat. So I’m frightened – and Destiny YouTuber Datto shares this concern, as you’ll be able to learn in our interview with him – that by catering to much less dedicated gamers by matchmaking, Anthem’s raids will really feel trivial in comparison with these of Destiny.
Related: Train your sights on the best shooters on PC
And but. More than as soon as I strung collectively an exciting sequence of flying, hovering, short-range dodges, and double-jumps, dropping grenades and LMG hearth on enemies as I went, and I felt a glimmer of one thing that would pull me away from Destiny. I’m not about to pre-order, however for some, a glimmer is perhaps all that’s wanted – Forsaken was terrific, however did it come too late? No one ought to overlook how bitter the Destiny subreddit was within the 12 months earlier than its launch.